Mrs. Ohtori. <- Previous • Next -> Shadow girls.
This is an easy one. The musical nerd boys make little progress over the series; their arc is nearly a straight line.
I call them nerd boys because of their glasses, but they are in fact ordinary boys. Their names are among the most common and undistinguished in Japan, and the boys are so undistinguished—and undistinguishable—that they are not given personal names. They can be told apart by their hair, eyes, and musically tuned voices. Otherwise they are identical and behave identically. The system of control has successfully pressed them into conformity. Nanami’s minions are different: They are individuals and are never quite in sync, even when they first decide to become Nanami’s minions.
The beneficiaries of the patriarchy have cause to conform to gain the benefits. The victims of the patriarchy have cause to resist and refuse conformity. Utena is an extreme case.
The boys are equated with elephants, implicitly in episode 8 and explicitly in episode 24. Elephants in Utena (at least these elephants) stand for predatory male pursuit of women. The boys stalk Nanami in episode 8 in the same way that the elephants stalk Nanami and her minions when they travel to India. (It’s no coincidence that predatory Akio originates from India.) Even when not pursuing Nanami, as in Nanami’s Egg episode 27, they are associated with Nanami.
Whether it’s supposed to or not, it comes off as a stereotype of Indians. India is huge and diverse and can do without stereotypes. Nevertheless, Indian culture by and large is claimed to be more patriarchal than Japanese culture, which is by and large more patriarchal than American or European culture—which are plenty patriarchal already.
So the claim is that ordinary boys are stalkers. They are not as bad as special boys like Saionji and Touga.
The boys pursue Nanami fruitlessly in most of their appearances. They call out to Wakaba in episode 20. In the epilog, they have given up on Nanami and pursue her minions instead. It does count as progress: Nanami is special and considers herself above their level, and her minions are ordinary girls and should be on the same level as the nerd boys. But their pursuit remains fruitless. There’s a little more discussion of the epilog at afterstories - the good make progress.
Jay Scott <email@example.com>
first posted 19 July 2023
updated 30 October 2023